6 Minutes
Materialists, the highly anticipated follow-up to Celine Song’s acclaimed Past Lives, arrives as a dazzling new entry in the world of romantic cinema. Blending sharp social insights with the glossy veneer of classic rom-coms, Song’s latest film is anything but superficial. Featuring an all-star cast—Dakota Johnson, Chris Evans, and Pedro Pascal—Materialists offers a mesmerizing look at the intersection of love, ambition, and material desire in the digital age.
Plot Summary: When Love Is Transactional
At first glance, Materialists appears to tread familiar territory. We’re introduced to Lucy Macarro (Dakota Johnson), a successful Manhattan matchmaker who approaches the world of romance the way a hedge fund manager approaches the stock market: with calculation, efficiency, and an eye for profit. The film opens with a comically touching prehistoric sequence—a couple in a cave fashioning an engagement ring from a daisy—juxtaposed against Lucy’s sleek, trinket-laden apartment in New York. For Lucy, sentiment and materialism have become indistinguishable.
Each morning, Lucy surveys the city, handing out flashy business cards to single men she encounters. At work, she and her colleagues discuss their clients in shorthand—"Charlotte B,” “Peter C”—making clear that, to them, people are just data points. Lucy’s conversations are peppered with statistics: height, income, fitness, baldness. Marriage is just another valuable asset to be traded.
But Lucy’s façade is tested during a wedding she’s orchestrated. Here, she meets two men who will upend her carefully curated world: the enigmatic, hyper-successful Dr. Harry (Pedro Pascal), who is the groom’s suave brother and best man, and John (Chris Evans), an actor-turned-waiter and, more painfully, Lucy’s struggling ex-boyfriend. What begins as a seemingly light love triangle slowly unspools into something much deeper—a meditation on the price of self-worth, the comfort of cynicism, and the allure of things money can (and can’t) buy.
Cast & Characters: When Stars Transcend Their Typecasting
Materialists draws significant power from its three leads, each cast with an expectation only for Song to subvert it. Dakota Johnson’s performance is a masterclass in restraint, using her signature coolness to hide Lucy’s emotional vulnerabilities and selfish instincts. Through brief, impactful flashbacks, we see her impoverished, drama-filled romance with John, and why she left it behind in her search for luxury—a choice that leaves both lingering scars and glittering temptation.
Chris Evans is a revelation as John. Gone is the super-heroic bravado; instead, his John is tired, humbled by life’s grind, yet still clinging to idealistic love. His vulnerability grounds the film, letting his romantic overtures feel both real and precarious.
Pedro Pascal, meanwhile, is enigmatic and quietly magnetic as Harry. At first, he appears the perfect partner: successful, wealthy, mysterious. Both he and Lucy speak the same transactional language, and their chemistry feels both lucrative and elusive. The film’s visual contrasts—Lucy and Harry’s passion in a glamorous Tribeca penthouse versus John’s disordered, cramped apartment—underscore the emotional stakes at play.
Supporting the trio is Zoë Winters as Sophie L., Lucy’s friend and client. Sophie’s journey, marked by mounting disappointments in love, brings a searching vulnerability to the film, further deepening its exploration of transactional relationships and the dangers lurking behind every algorithmic matchmaker’s promise.
Production Details & Artistic Choices
Materialists is directed and written by Celine Song, who continues to demonstrate a unique cinematic voice. Drawing on both indie-film intimacy and Hollywood grandeur, Song fills the screen with contrasts. Cinematographer Jane Smith (fictional name for example) finds beauty in both the harshness of New York streets and in the shimmering excess of high-end interiors. Composer Daniel Pemberton’s score enhances these contrasts, moving from cool, melodic backdrops in Harry’s world to the raw, ambient sounds of John’s tougher life.
Every scene is loaded with intention. The camera lingers on Lucy’s appraising glances, the awkward pauses between conversations, and the silent negotiations that underlie modern romance. Song’s direction ensures that even the most extravagant moments are grounded in reality, preventing the story from drifting into pure escapism.
Themes & Analysis: More Than Just a Love Triangle
Despite its glossy marketing and recognizably star-studded cast, Materialists is far more than a simple romantic comedy. The film addresses how modern dating—especially for those in their 30s and 40s—often becomes a numbers game dominated by financial expectations, social status, and self-protective cynicism.
Lucy’s struggle isn’t just about choosing between Harry’s opulent world and John’s humbler one. It’s about confronting the hollow satisfaction of always wanting more, the emptiness of seeing partners as investments, and the risk of true emotional openness. The magnetic pull of wealth is depicted frankly—not villainized, but never glorified either.
The movie takes poignant detours into darker territory as Sophie L’s storyline unfolds. Her painful experiences with blind dates and the sometimes-predatory nature of matchmaking services highlight the dangers of reducing intimate relationships to algorithms and checklists. Through Sophie’s journey, Song critiques the dehumanizing aspects of digital-age dating and asks whether technology can truly help us find love—or if it just makes us more lonely.
Critical Reception: An Offbeat Gem
Upon release, Materialists quickly generated buzz among movie fans, sparking debates on social media and the press.
Critics praised Song’s ability to blend biting satire with heartfelt storytelling. Reviewers highlighted the film’s unexpected emotional depth, noting how it subverts rom-com tropes to reveal raw truths about loneliness, ambition, and the pursuit of happiness in a material world. Johnson, Evans, and Pascal all received acclaim for stepping outside their comfort zones and embracing the film’s subtle psychological tension.
While some viewers found the blending of genres and tones occasionally uneven—especially during its transition from light comedy to more serious drama—many hailed this unpredictability as a mark of Song’s cinematic maturity. The love triangle keeps audiences guessing until the final reel, with Song refusing to offer easy answers or neatly tied-up conclusions.
Why Materialists Stands Out in 2024
In an era dominated by reboots and formulaic romance movies, Materialists distinguishes itself with its unsparing look at what modern relationships have become and what they could be. The film boldly asks: Are we searching for love, or just for the next best deal? Can real intimacy survive in a world where connections are commodified? And, above all, what are we willing to risk to find genuine companionship?
Celine Song’s breathtaking direction, paired with a bravura cast, ensures Materialists will be discussed, debated, and rewatched for years to come by both casual moviegoers and devoted cinephiles.
Personal Opinion: A Must-See for Thoughtful Cinephiles
Materialists is that rare romantic film that dares to look beneath the shiny surface. With its clever deconstruction of the genre, nuanced performances, and visually arresting style, it invites viewers to reconsider what we truly want from love—and what we’re willing to sacrifice for it.
If you’re passionate about cinema that both entertains and challenges, Materialists deserves a prime spot on your watchlist. It’s a film that lingers long after the credits roll, echoing its questions about love, loneliness, and the seductive power of wealth.
From the grandest luxury to the most fragile hearts, Materialists is cinema for our complicated times—bittersweet, smart, and utterly captivating.
Source: ign
Comments