6 Minutes
An Old-School Hollywood Crime Thriller Lost in the 2010s
When superhero franchises and adrenaline-fueled sequels dominated Hollywood, few films dared to bring back the unapologetic grit of classic crime cinema. Yet, in 2013, director Ruben Fleischer unleashed 'Gangster Squad'—a stylish, action-packed gangster movie that paid homage to the noir tradition of the 1930s and ‘40s. Headlined by Josh Brolin and Ryan Gosling, and supported by an all-star cast including Sean Penn and Emma Stone, this underrated gem blends cinematic nostalgia with explosive modern spectacle.
Plot Summary: The Battle for Los Angeles
Set in the shadow-drenched streets of postwar Los Angeles, 'Gangster Squad' follows LAPD Sergeant John O’Mara (Josh Brolin), a decorated World War II veteran determined to restore order to a city slipping into chaos. O’Mara is tasked by police chief Bill Parker (Nick Nolte) to assemble a covert squad and wage war against the notorious East Coast mobster Mickey Cohen (Sean Penn), a ruthless crime boss whose influence seeps through the police force and courtrooms alike.
The squad includes Jerry Wooters (Ryan Gosling), a charismatic detective and fellow veteran; Coleman Harris (Anthony Mackie), an expert with knives; Max Kennard (Robert Patrick), a legendary sharpshooter; wiretap specialist Conwell Keeler (Giovanni Ribisi); and rookie Navidad Ramirez (Michael Peña). Together, they dive deep into L.A.'s criminal underworld, targeting Cohen’s thriving casino empire and various vice rackets. As the crew’s clandestine campaign intensifies, they find themselves facing escalating danger—not only from Cohen’s vengeful wrath, but also from the blurring lines between justice and lawlessness.
The Cast and Crew: Stellar Performances and Creative Vision
'Gangster Squad' is powered by a remarkable ensemble cast. Josh Brolin delivers a commanding performance as John O’Mara, a lawman torn between duty, violence, and family. Ryan Gosling shines as the suave, morally ambiguous Jerry Wooters, while Emma Stone brings her signature charm and emotional depth as Grace Faraday, Cohen’s glamorous paramour and Wooters’ love interest.
Sean Penn’s menacing turn as Mickey Cohen offers a villain both larger-than-life and chillingly real, reminiscent of Hollywood’s classic crime antagonists. Directed by Ruben Fleischer—renowned for his kinetic visual storytelling in films like 'Zombieland' and 'Venom'—'Gangster Squad' is visually vibrant, weaving comic book-style action with lush period detail. The production design lovingly recreates 1940s Los Angeles, from its neon-lit clubs to the shadow-dark alleys where justice is forged.
Production Notes: Style, Action, and Tragedy Behind the Scenes
The movie’s journey to the big screen was not without turbulence. Originally set for a 2012 release, 'Gangster Squad' faced a significant delay after a real-life tragedy—the Aurora theater shooting during a screening of 'The Dark Knight Rises'—forced the studio to re-edit and reshoot scenes involving a pivotal movie-theater shootout. This reworking inevitably affected the film’s pacing and tone, but the finished product remains a stylish action thriller with all the hallmarks of the gangster movie genre.
Fleischer's direction pays tribute to noir classics while also infusing the story with the visceral impact modern audiences crave. The film’s high-octane action sequences, sharp dialogue, and dazzling period costumes conjure an immersive cinematic world, even as they flirt with stylized exaggeration.
Critical Reception: Ambition Meets Mixed Reviews
Despite its dazzling cast and stunning visuals, 'Gangster Squad' met with a lukewarm reception from critics, earning just a 30% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. While some praised the film’s energetic action and Brolin’s old-school heroism, others felt the narrative lacked nuance, with its clear-cut battle between good and evil reminiscent of black-and-white classics like 'Little Caesar', 'Scarface', and 'White Heat'. Yet, for crime movie aficionados and fans of gangster dramas, this unashamedly pulpy approach is part of the film’s charm.
While it didn’t climb to the genre heights of 'The Untouchables' or 'L.A. Confidential', 'Gangster Squad' stands as a love letter to classic mob movies, revitalized for a new era of action cinema.
Josh Brolin: Hollywood’s Reluctant Vigilante
A significant reason to rewatch 'Gangster Squad' today lies in the magnetic performance by Josh Brolin. As John O’Mara, Brolin embodies the stoic, hard-edged hero—a throwback to screen icons like Clint Eastwood and Charles Bronson. Unlike more procedural crimefighters, O’Mara isn’t afraid to get his hands dirty, meting out rough justice in the pursuit of order.
This moral complexity is palpable throughout the film. O’Mara, a devoted husband and father, becomes increasingly compromised as he battles crime with near-vigilante zeal, putting everything he loves on the line. The tension between integrity and obsession gives 'Gangster Squad' its emotional undercurrent, elevating the film above mere genre exercise.
Why 'Gangster Squad' is Worth a Watch Today
In a streaming landscape overflowing with superheroes and reboots, 'Gangster Squad' offers a bracing alternative: a star-studded crime thriller imbued with the spirit of old Hollywood. Its visual flair, thrilling set pieces, and captivating cast recall a time when Hollywood’s heroes didn’t wear spandex—they wore fedoras and carried a badge.
For fans of classic gangster films, modern action, and big-screen charisma, 'Gangster Squad' deserves a spot on your must-watch list. Currently available on Prime Video in the US, it’s the perfect opportunity to revisit—or discover for the first time—this overlooked jewel of modern crime cinema.
Comments