Why Quentin Tarantino Passed the Baton to David Fincher for the Netflix 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood' Follow-Up

Why Quentin Tarantino Passed the Baton to David Fincher for the Netflix 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood' Follow-Up

2025-08-16
0 Comments Lena Carter

5 Minutes

Introduction

In a surprising turn for cinephiles, David Fincher will direct the Netflix follow-up to Quentin Tarantino’s 2019 hit Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, with Brad Pitt officially returning as Cliff Booth. Tarantino recently explained his reasons on The Church of Tarantino podcast, revealing why he opted not to direct the project himself — and why Fincher might be the perfect match for this Hollywood-centric sequel.

Plot Summary

Official plot details remain deliberately scarce. What is known is that the follow-up revolves around Cliff Booth, the laconic stuntman played by Brad Pitt in the original film. Rather than a direct recreation of Tarantino’s earlier beats, the new story is meant to continue Booth’s arc in a fresh chapter of late-1960s Los Angeles. The screenplay was written by Tarantino himself, but the tone and visual language will be filtered through Fincher’s distinct directorial style, promising a darker, more meticulous take on the same era of Hollywood mythology.

Cast and Crew

Cast

Brad Pitt is confirmed to reprise his role as Cliff Booth. Other casting announcements are pending; industry observers are watching closely for potential returns or fresh faces from the world of cinema and television.

Crew

David Fincher is attached as director for the Netflix production, a move that surprised many fans who had expected Tarantino to helm his own follow-up. Quentin Tarantino remains deeply involved as the screenwriter and a producer, and he has stated he will be available as needed while splitting time between locations.

Production Details

Netflix is developing the project with a high-profile production pipeline, leveraging both Tarantino’s screenplay and Fincher’s cinematic craftsmanship. Tarantino confirmed he won’t be on set every day — he’s traveling between the U.S. and Israel — but will be present when required. The collaboration between a writer-director like Tarantino and a formalist auteur like Fincher highlights an unusual creative partnership in contemporary film production: the original author of the story ceding direction to a peer he respects.

Why Tarantino Stepped Aside

Tarantino explained that after nearly three decades of filmmaking, he didn’t want his tenth and purportedly final movie to be a sequel. He described a personal challenge to end his directorial career in "uncharted territory" rather than revisiting familiar ground. Rather than an unwillingness to engage with the material, his decision reflects a desire for artistic risk — and a high opinion of Fincher’s ability to do justice to the script.

Critical Reception and Industry Buzz

While the film has not yet been released, the announcement ignited studio and critical interest. Industry reaction has focused on the novelty of Tarantino writing for another director and on how Fincher’s disciplined visual approach might reshape a Tarantino-created world. Anticipation is high among movie critics, film blogs, and fans tracking Netflix’s strategy for prestige cinema and auteur-driven streaming releases.

On "The Movie Critic" and Creative Choices

Tarantino also discussed why he shelved a long-teased project titled The Movie Critic. He admitted it was a risky conceit — trying to turn the life of a film critic into compelling cinema — and treated the concept as a "test" of his ability to revive what many would consider an unglamorous protagonist. He clarified that The Movie Critic was intended as a "spiritual sequel" to Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, not a direct crossover; Cliff Booth was never part of that story.

Personal Take

For lovers of auteur cinema, this collaboration is thrilling: Tarantino’s sharp, period-savvy writing paired with Fincher’s precision could yield a unique hybrid of style and substance. Whether the final film leans more toward Tarantino’s character-driven pastiche or Fincher’s psychological exactitude, this Netflix follow-up is poised to be one of the most closely watched film releases in the coming cycle.

"I’m Lena. Binge-watcher, story-lover, critic at heart. If it’s worth your screen time, I’ll let you know!"

Comments

Leave a Comment